

Neighborhood Trust Destroyed
Tell Us About Your Situation
No items found.
The law enforcement interview of the alleged victim helped the defense convince a jury to acquit the accused.
Case Summary
The accusation
That Jack fondled the genitals of Katie, his five-year-old next-door neighbor, while giving her a back scratch she had asked for.
The charge
Child Molestation in the First Degree.
The possible sentence
life in prison.
The defense David Marshall presented
The story Katie told did not add up. By all accounts, Jack had had many opportunities to molest Katie, as she often came to his home to play with his grandsons. Yet she said he had molested her only once, on an occasion far less private than many other opportunities. Also, she showed no reluctance to be around Jack after that occasion—until she had a conversation with her mother in which, according to the mother, she reported molestation.
The trial result
Jack was acquitted by the jury in less than an hour.
What helped win the case
As in most child sex abuse cases involving young children, the prosecutor’s evidence included a complete report of the child’s interview by law enforcement. Most often defense lawyers attack the law enforcement interviewer’s work, suggesting leading questions elicited false allegations. Here, David took the opposite approach. He lauded the interviewer’s work and noted that the only allegation it had produced was Katie’s statement that Jack had “scratched” her by her “pee-pee.” Even a five-year-old, David argued, would use a word other than “scratched” (maybe “rubbed”) to describe fondling of her genitals, if she had truly experienced it. Katie had used “scratched” because she had an accurate memory of Jack scratching her back, on her request.
No items found.
Testimonials
Reviews

Contact a Seattle Criminal Defense Lawyer
Committed Support Throughout Your Legal Process
Defending against an accusation of a sex crime, child abuse, or domestic violence is not easy. If you’ve been accused, let us help you.
Marshall & Saunders
901 Fifth Avenue, Suite 2800
Seattle, Washington 98164
901 Fifth Avenue, Suite 2800
Seattle, Washington 98164
You will receive a response from us within 1 - 2 business days.
Please do not share any confidential information until we have confirmed there are no conflicts of interest. We will contact you to discuss your situation further.
Thank You!
Your message has been submitted.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.